Pressed Penny Wish List

We love collecting pressed pennies from places we have visited!  Sometimes though we don’t have any change at all (shame on us!) or not enough to get the entire set. Or the machine might be out of order.  Other times, we were unaware that a location was host to a penny machine until after we got back home.

Please see the bottom of the list for penny sets we currently have available for trade.

At any rate, we are looking to add the following smashed pennies to our collection…

Our Pressed Penny Wish List

The ones in red are our most-wanted ones!


  • Cape Canaveral – Jetty Park
  • Eglin Air Force Base – Air Force Armament Museum
  • Jacksonville – Jacksonville Zoo
  • Orlando – Gatorland (need pennies from machine #2)
  • Orlando – Sea World (have some retired designs but would love the newer ones)
  • St Augustine – St. Augustine & St. Johns County Visitor Information Center
  • Titusville – Kennedy Space Center
  • Walt Disney World – Epcot World Showcase – China Pavilion
  • Walt Disney World – Epcot World Showcase – Japan Pavilion


  • Atlanta – World of Coca Cola
  • Lookout Mountain – Rock City
  • Stone Mountain – Stone Mountain Park


  • Porter – Indiana Dunes Visitor Center
  • Shipshewanna – Davis Mercantile
  • Metamora – Family Touch Primitive Treasures and Cafe
  • Elkhart – Indiana Turnpike
  • Indianapolis – Children’s Museum
  • Marengo – Marengo Cave (need the dime, have the penny designs)
  • Mauckport – Squire Boone Caverns (We have a set, but the pennies all rolled short.  Would love a set where the text is legible.)


  • Springfield – Lincoln’s Tomb Souvenir & Gift Shop


  • Cave City – Olde General Store (need the KY outline and galloping horse designs from machine #2)
  • Fort Knox – Patton Museum of Cavalry and Armor (need the Patton, tank, and colt 45 designs)
  • Hodgenville – The Lincoln Museum
  • Horse Cave – Kentucky Down Under (need the vertical Kangaroo and Lorikeet designs)
  • Lexington – Kentucky Horse Park (need the Man O’ War design, have the galloping horses one)
  • Newport – Hofbrau Haus (retired)
  • Petersburg – Creation Museum (only need the kangaroo design as it wasn’t rolling correctly while we were there)


  • Battle Creek – Kellogg’s Cereal City
  • Dundee – Cabela’s (need machine #2)
  • Frankenmuth – Cass River Bar and Game Room
  • Frankenmuth – Michigan Shoppe
  • Traverse City – Great Wolf Lodge


  • Bloomington – Bubba Gump Shrimp Company at the Mall of America
  • Bloomington – I Love Minnesota Store in the Mall of America (need the Minnesota Bound and I love you Minnesota designs)
  • Bloomington – Rainforest Cafe at the Mall of America
  • Walnut Grove – Laura Ingalls Wilder Museum


  • St Louis – Gateway Arch Jefferson National Expansion Memorial 

New York

  • Castile – Letchworth State Park
  • New York City – Ellis Island Immigration Museum
  • Niagara Falls – Rainforest Cafe (would also like the pressed tokens from the Rainforest Cafe in Ontario)
  • Niagara Falls – Cave of the Winds Gift Shop (need the elevator building, state flag, and Big Apple designs)
  • Niagara Falls – Cave of the Winds food stand (need the Cave of the Winds, Horseshoe Falls, and Empire State designs)
  • Niagara Falls – Gift Shop below Top of the Falls Restaurant (need the NY state bird and Theodore Roosevelt designs)
  • Niagara Falls – Visitors Center lower level (need the power project and black squirrel designs)
  • Niagara Falls – Prospect Point Visitor Center lower level (need the Chief Richard, Erie Canal, and state flower designs)
  • Niagara Falls Prospect Point Visitor Center lower level (need all 4 designs)
  • Any other Niagara Falls pressed pennies that we don’t have (check out the Niagara Falls pressed pennies in our collection to see the ones we already have)
  • Olcott – Olcott Beach Carousel Park

North Carolina

  • Cherokee – Ravenhawk Gifts
  • Cherokee – Smoky Mountain Trader II, Minnetonka Moccasin


  • Columbus – COSI
  • Lucas – Malabar Farm State Park
  • Marblehead – Marblehead Lighthouse (from the new machine – we have the retired ones)


  • Gettysburg – Gettysburg Diorama
  • Hershey – Hershey’s Chocolate World
  • Hershey – Hershey Museum (need logo and teepee designs)
  • King of Prussia – Valley Forge National Historical Park Welcome Center (pending)
  • Philadelphia – Independence Visitor’s Center (Independence Hall and Liberty Bell designs)
  • Punxsutawney – Punxsutawney Phil’s Official Souvenir Shop


  • Chattanooga – Tennessee Aquarium
  • Chattanooga – Lookout Mountain Incline Railway
  • Chattanooga – Ruby Falls (need Ruby Falls text design and Lookout Mountain design)
  • Gatlinburg – Mountain Mall (need eagle design)
  • Gatlinburg – Ripleys Believe It or Not
  • Nashville – Opryland Hotel
  • Nashville – Opryland Amusement Park (park has been torn down but at one time had 8 penny designs)
  • Nashville – Opry Mills Mall (near food court)
  • Pigeon Forge – Country Barn Gift Shop
  • Pigeon Forge – Mine Your Own Gem Mine (pennies from both machines #1 and #2)


  • Salt Lake City – The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints History Museum

Washington DC

  • Smithsonian Castle
  • White House Visitor’s Center


  • Spring Valley – Crystal Cave (need machine #2)
  • Wisconsin Dells – Ripley’s Believe It or Not
  • Wisconsin Dells – Kalahari Resort
  • Wisconsin Dells – H.H. Bennett Studio & History Center (need the 4 leaf clover design)


  • Jamaica – Dolphin Cove in Ocho Rios

If you have any of the designs we are looking for, please send us an email at
pressedpennymuseum at gmail dot com. We would love to trade with you!